Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Netanyahu's "Optimism"

At a Likud party meeting two days ago, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyhau said he optimistic about the Israeli-Palestinian peace process. One has to wonder: What does he mean by "optimistic?" Does this optimism mean that Netanyahu thinks there will be progress in the peace process, or does he think the opposite: that the process, which is useless to begin with, will fall apart soon.

This cynicism comes from a very problematic fact, that the PM has promoted a policy that he himself does not believe in. Rather than finding a true alternative to "two states for two nations," Netanyahu prefers a policy of minimizing damages by using the failed equation that has practically become Obama's slogan, while demanding preconditions that contradict the entire process.

Recognizing the State of Israel as a Jewish state, along with any recognition of the justness of Zionism, contradicts the logic behind a two-state solution. The Palestinian narrative, which sees the Arabs living in Israel as a separate nation, was created in the 1960s as a way to de-legitimize Zionism. If Zionism is not a crime, then the Palestinians are simply Arabs, some of whom left Israel when the state was formed in 1948. This is a simple humanitarian problem that could have been solved 50 years ago and can be solved now, especially when considering myriad Arab states in the world.

The creation of a Palestinian State is impossible. It has no geopolitical, military or economic logic behind it. It is a failed formula that the world has not let go because of Palestinian propaganda and the lack of an alternative solution. Rather than show optimism about a process that he doesn't believe in, Prime Minister Netanyahu would be better off if he thought outside of the box and adopted a new plan. This plan would offer peace in the simplest terms: prosperity, security and rights for all, without paying lip service to the Palestinian national narrative, whose contribution to recent history has only been frustration and bloodshed.

2 comments:

  1. You're right, the likelihood of Palestinian statehood is getting smaller and smaller with every passing day. Before that there has to be peace. It would be suicide to allow the West Bank to turn into another Gaza Strip.

    Netanyahu's best course of action in my view is to continue paying lip service to those that call for two states, knowing full well that it will never happen as long as the Palestinians lack unity and vision, and meanwhile improve economic conditions and sort out the social / sectarian problems at a local level.

    Priority number one needs to be addressing the hatred and small-scale violence (rock throwing, petrol bombs, vandalism etc) through education and professional policing. Remove checkpoints as a reward for good behaviour.

    What are your thoughts on settlement building?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I believe Israel has every right to build settlements. I am all for the Israeli Initiative! It's the only sane proposal!
    We need to pray daily for Israel and Netanyahu's leadership. For wisdom and a strong hearing from Yah!

    ReplyDelete