UN General Assembly Celebrates 60 Years of UNRWA's Lack of Acheivements

Agency Has Perpetuated Palestinian "Refugeehood" For Sixty Years

This week's United Nations General Assembly has been marked by a week-long commemoration of 60 years of "achievements and service" by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA). At a press conference in New York, Karen Koning Abu-Zayd, Commisioner-General of UNRWA, declared that the commemoration was a tribute to the refugees themselves, who thrived "despite being refugees for such a long time and under occupation for 40 of those 60 years." She also emphasized the importance of aiding refugee youth.

It is hard to understand what achievements UNRWA has had that are worth celebrating. Although the agency provides services such as food and education to Palestinian refugees, it has helped cause stagnation and complacency with their current status. While all other refugees, treated by UNHCR, the United Nations High Commisioner for Refugees, are resettled within two years, Palestinian refugees have remained in camps for 60 years, without help in rehabilitation from UNRWA.

"Western countries, which have sought to help the Palestinians, have, over the course of six decades, donated millions to UNRWA – an agency that has not rehabilitated even one refugee, and never will," emphasized former Israeli cabinet minister Benny Elon, founder of The Israeli Initiative. "UNRWA does not serve the Palestinian population; rather, it serves the Palestinian national narrative, and thus eternalizes the conflict, offering the refugees war and blood instead of welfare and life. The time has come to stop the cash flow to UNRWA and once and for all, with a just solution, deal with the refugee problem. Transferring the refugees to UNHCR's care, after 60 years under UNRWA, would be such a solution."

According to Israeli Initiative researcher Gideon Israel, "Sources working in the refugee camps have reported that 90% of the refugees in Gaza would like to emigrate to Western countries, and there are similar statistics for other Palestinian refugees. Contrary to the myth that no states are willing to accept refugees, there are actually many that would absorb Palestinian refugees, such as Canada or Chile. In fact, Palestinian refugees in Iraq were recently relocated to Iceland, Slovakia, Norway and the United States. However, these refugees were under UNHCR's care, not UNRWA. "

Although Abu-Zayd claimed that her greatest wish is to see the end of Palestinian refugeehood, UNRWA's actions speak louder than their words, and those actions say that UNRWA plays no part in rehabilitating refugees. Millions of Palestinians under UNRWA's care are sentenced to remain refugees forever – that is, as long as the State of Israel exists.

There is also an issue with Abu-Zayd's emphasis of the so-called occupation. The majority of Palestinian refugees are not in Israel, therefore the claim that most have been under occupation for 40 years is wrong. Israel cannot be blamed for the refugee situation, when there are many options that are not being sought for the Palestinian refugees, such as the ten countries which have agreed to participate in the UNHCR's refugee absorption program.